旅游领域量表开发研究进展——基于国内外六本旅游学术刊物的分析

doi:10.12054/lydk.bisu.56

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

本文通过对1998—2017年间发表在国内外6本旅游学术刊物上的53篇论文的统计分析,对旅游研究领域量表开发的历程、主题、流程规范与心理测量学标准进行了回顾。研究发现：（1）国内外旅游领域的量表开发研究可以划分为缓慢起步期（1998—2007）和快速发展期（2008—2017）两个阶段。（2）主要的研究领域为游客、旅游目的地和目的地居民。（3）在量表开发流程方面,初始测项确定、正式样本收集、信度与效度分析是目前旅游研究领域量表开发论文普遍遵循的步骤;但在构念范围确定、初始测项净化、问卷预试、探索性因子分析和验证性因子分析等5个步骤上,不少论文尚未严格遵守基本流程。（4）绝大部分论文都严格遵守量表开发的心理测量学标准,汇报了符合心理测量学标准的统计结果。本文的研究发现能为旅游领域后续新量表的开发提供主题领域选择以及流程与技术指标上的参考。

关键词: 量表开发; 旅游研究; 发展历程; 量表开发流程; 心理测量学标准

Abstract:

This paper reviews 53 articles of measurement scale development published in six tourism journals (i.e., Annals of Tourism Research,Journal of Sustainable Tourism, Journal of Travel Research, Tourism Management, Tourism Science, and Tourism Tribune) between 1998 and 2017 to elucidate the developmental stages, topical areas and scale development process and statistical standards in the field of tourism studies. It is found that: (1) Studies on measurement scale development in tourism could be diachronically divided into two stages, namely the initial stage (1998-2007) and the quickly-developing stage (2008-2017). (2) The major research areas where measurement scales have been mostly developed are tourists (e.g., tourists’ perceptions, attitudes, and satisfaction), destination (e.g., destination image, brand equity, and sustainability), and residents (e.g., residents’ perceptions of and attitudes towards tourism development, and host-guest interactions). (3) Regarding the process of measurement scale development, the commonly followed procedures are generation of scale items, data collection, and assessment of reliability and validity. However, some measurement scale development studies have not strictly followed the procedures in terms of specification of the domains of construct, purification of scale items, pilot data collection, explorative factor analysis, and confirmative factor analysis, to a varying extent. On the contrary, most of the analyzed articles have strictly followed the psychometric standards in measurement scale development and reported the statistical analysis results that justified the psychometric properties of the scales that were newly developed and/or validated. The findings derived from this paper are believed to be able to guide future measurement scale development studies in the field of tourism in terms of research topics, development procedures, and psychometric properties required.

Keywords: measurement scale development; tourism studies; developmental stage; scale development procedure; psychometric properties

中图分类号:

陈钢华, 赵丽君. 旅游领域量表开发研究进展——基于国内外六本旅游学术刊物的分析[J]. 旅游导刊, 2017, 1(6): 66-85.

Ganghua CHEN, Lijun ZHAO. Measurement Scale Development in the Study of Tourism: An Analysis of Publications in Six Tourism Journals[J]. Tourism and Hospitality Prospects, 2017, 1(6): 66-85.

图/表 12

参考文献 48

[1]	罗伯特•F•德威利斯. 量表编制: 理论与应用[M]. 魏勇刚, 龙长权,宋武,译. 2版. 重庆: 重庆大学出版社, 2004.
[2]	Woosnam K M, Norman W C.Measuring residents’ emotional solidarity with tourists: Scale development of Durkheim’s theoretical constructs[J]. Journal of Travel Research, 2010, 49(3): 365~380.
[3]	Churchill Jr G A. A paradigm for developing better measures of marketing constructs[J]. Journal of Marketing Research, 1979, 16(1): 64~73.
[4]	康红星. 服务质量测量及量表开发研究[D]. 长沙: 中南大学, 2006.
[5]	Kong H Y, Cheung C, Zhang H Q.Career management systems: What are China’s state-owned hotels practising?[J]. International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management, 2010, 22(4): 467~482.
[6]	Chen G H, Bao J G, Huang S S.Developing a scale to measure backpackers’ personal development[J]. Journal of Travel Research, 2014, 53(4): 522~536. ?
[7]	Chen G H, Huang S S.Toward a theory of backpacker personal development: Cross-cultural validation of the BPD scale[J]. Tourism Management, 2017(59): 630~639.
[8]	Chen G H, Huang S S, Zhang D D.Understanding Chinese vacationers’ perceived destination restorative qualities: Cross-cultural validation of the perceived destination restorative qualities scale[J]. Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing, 2017, 34(8): 1115~1127.
[9]	Kim J H, Ritchie J R B, McCormick B. Development of a scale to measure memorable tourism experiences[J]. Journal of Travel Research, 2012, 51(1): 12~25.
[10]	Lehto X Y.Assessing the perceived restorative qualities of vacation destinations[J]. Journal of Travel Research, 2013, 52(3): 325~339.
[11]	Barnes S J, Mattsson J, Sørensen F.Destination brand experience and visitor behavior: Testing a scale in the tourism context[J]. Annals of Tourism Research, 2014(48): 121~139.
[12]	Albacete-Sáez C A, Fuentes-Fuentes M M, Lloréns-Montes F J. Service quality measurement in rural accommodation[J]. Annals of Tourism Research, 2007, 34(1): 45~65.
[13]	Frochot I, Hughes H.HISTOQUAL: The development of a historic houses assessment scale[J]. Tourism Management, 2000, 21(2): 157~167.
[14]	Incites. Journal Citation Reports[EB/OL]. , 2017-06-16.
[15]	McKercher B, Law R, Lam T. Rating tourism and hospitality journals[J]. Tourism Management, 2006, 27(6): 1235~1252.
[16]	阳翼,卢泰宏.中国独生代价值观系统的研究:一个量表的开发与检验[J]. 营销科学学报,2007,3(3):104~114.
[17]	Yoo B, Donthu N.Developing and validating a multidimensional consumer-based brand equity scale[J]. Journal of Business Research, 2001, 52(1): 1~14.
[18]	胡宪洋, 白凯. 旅游目的地形象修复方式量表探讨: 中外游客整合对比的视角[J]. 旅游学刊, 2013, 28(9): 73~83.
[19]	周晓宏, 郭文静. 探索性因子分析与验证性因子分析异同比较[J]. 科技和产业, 2008, 8(9): 69~71.
[20]	Hair J F, Black B, Babin B, et al.Multivariate Data Analysis[M]. 6th ed. New York: Prentice Hall, 2006:67.
[21]	张超, 徐燕, 陈平雁.探索性因子分析与验证性因子分析在量表研究中的比较与应用[J]. 南方医科大学学报, 2007, 27(11): 1699~1700, 1705.
[22]	Kaiser H F.A second generation little jiffy[J]. Psychometrika, 1970, 35(4): 401~415.
[23]	郭毅, 侯丽敏, 戚海峰, 等. 基于关系视角的营销理论[M]. 上海: 华东理工大学出版社, 2006: 197.
[24]	王长义, 王大鹏, 赵晓雯, 等. 结构方程模型中拟合指数的运用与比较[J]. 现代预防医学, 2010, 37(1): 7~9.
[25]	邱蕾. 基于Monte Carlo模拟的结构方程模型拟合优度指数的性能比较研究[D]. 重庆: 重庆医科大学, 2013.
[26]	Reise S P, Waller N G, Comrey A L.Factor analysis and scale revision[J]. Psychological Assessment, 2000, 12(3): 287~297.
[27]	Hair J F, Tatham R L, Anderson R E, et al.Multivariate Data Analysis[M]. 5th ed. Upper Saddle River, New Jersey: Prentice Hall, 1998: 176.
[28]	Bohrnstedt G W, Borgatta E F.Social Measurement: Current Issues[M]. Beverly Hills, CA: STAGEPublishing, 1981: 65~115.
[29]	Hu L T, Bentler P M.Cutoff criteria for fit indexes in covariance structure analysis: Conventional criteria versus new alternatives[J]. Structural Equation Modeling: A Multidisciplinary Journal, 1999, 6(1): 1~55.
[30]	吴明隆. 结构方程模型——AMOS的操作与应用[M]. 重庆: 重庆大学出版社, 2009: 212~263.
[31]	Etezadi-Amoli J, Farhoomand A F.A structural model of enduser computing satisfaction and user performance[J]. Information & Management, 1996, 30(2): 65~73.
[32]	Bentler P M, Bonett D G.Significance tests and goodness of fit in the analysis of covariance structures[J]. Psychological Bulletin, 1980, 88(3): 588~606.
[33]	王伯文. 民宿体验、旅游意象、游客满意度与忠诚度影响关系之研究——以奋起湖地区为例[D]. 嘉义: 南华大学, 2005: 63~64.
[34]	Straub D W.Validating instruments in MIS research[J]. MIS Quarterly, 1989, 13(2): 146~169.
[35]	Nunnally J C, Bemstein I H.Psychometric Theory[M]. 3rd ed. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1994: 57~70.
[36]	Bagozzi R P, Kimmel S K.A comparison of leading theories for the prediction of goal-directed behaviours[J]. British Journal of Social Psychology, 1995, 34(4): 437~461.
[37]	董奇. 心理与教育研究方法[M]. 北京: 北京师范大学出版社, 2004.
[38]	Clark-Carter D.Doing Quantitative Psychological Research:From Design to Report[M]. Hove: Psychology Press, 1997.
[39]	Bailey R, Ball S.An exploration of the meanings of hotel brand equity[J]. The Service Industries Journal, 2006, 26(1): 15~38.
[40]	Byrne B M.Structural Equation Modeling with AMOS:Basic Concepts,Applications,and Programming[M]. 2nd ed. New York, NY: Routledge Taylor & Francis Group, 2010.
[41]	Hung K, Petrick J F.Developing a measurement scale for constraints to cruising[J]. Annals of Tourism Research, 2010, 37(1): 206~228.
[42]	Hair J F, Black W C, Babin B J, et al.Multivariate Data Analysis:A Global Perspective[M]. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Education, 2010: 34.
[43]	Anderson J C, Gerbing D W.Structural equation modeling in practice: A review and recommended two-step approach[J]. Psychological Bulletin, 1988, 103(3): 411~423.
[44]	Tull D S, Hawkins D I.Marketing Research:Measurement and Method[M]. 6th ed. New York: Macmillan Publisher, 1993:36.
[45]	徐玉梅. 国内外旅游研究格局分析[D]. 合肥: 安徽大学, 2016.
[46]	汪德根, 陈田, 王金莲, 等. 1980—2009年国内外旅游研究比较[J]. 地理学报, 2011, 66(4): 535~548.
[47]	朴志娜, 吴必虎, Morrison A M, 等. 全球旅游研究格局的综合分析(2003—2012)[J]. 旅游学刊, 2015, 30(7): 108~118.
[48]	林崇德. 心理学大辞典[M]. 上海: 上海教育出版社, 2003: 1404.

期刊	论文数量	所占比例（%）
Tourism Management	17	32.08
Journal of Travel Research	17	32.08
《旅游学刊》	8	15.09
Annals of Tourism Research	7	13.21
Journal of Sustainable Tourism	2	3.77
《旅游科学》	2	3.77

期刊	论文数量	所占比例（%）
Tourism Management	17	32.08
Journal of Travel Research	17	32.08
《旅游学刊》	8	15.09
Annals of Tourism Research	7	13.21
Journal of Sustainable Tourism	2	3.77
《旅游科学》	2	3.77

研究主题	论文数量	所占比例（%）
游客	25	47.17
旅游目的地	14	26.41
目的地居民	7	13.21
旅游业从业人员	6	11.32
旅游教育与培训	1	1.89

研究主题	论文数量	所占比例（%）
游客	25	47.17
旅游目的地	14	26.41
目的地居民	7	13.21
旅游业从业人员	6	11.32
旅游教育与培训	1	1.89

发展方式分类	论文数量	所占比例（%）
文献	17	32.08
访谈	3	5.66
结合多种方式（文献、访谈、网络文本分析等）	33	62.26